Wednesday, March 22, 2023
Chuck Marunde, J.D., Broker/Owner 360-775-5424


iRealty Virtual Brokers


Broker/Consultant

Washington State

SUBSCRIBE
  • Home
  • Search MLS
    • Sequim MLS
    • Sequim MLS Map Search
    • Port Angeles MLS
    • Port Townsend MLS
    • San Juan Islands MLS
    • All Islands MLS
    • How to Search the Sequim MLS
  • Videos
    • Sequim Videos Q&A
    • Buyer Videos Part 1
    • Buyer Videos Part 2
    • Buyer Videos Part 3
    • Buyer Videos Part 4
    • Living in Sequim Video Channel
  • Books
    The Coming Real Estate Crash

    The Coming Real Estate Crash

    The Sequim Real Estate Trilogy

    The Sequim Real Estate Trilogy

    Sequim Real Estate Videos for Buyers: The Ultimate Video Guide for Sequim Washington

    Sequim Real Estate Videos for Buyers: The Ultimate Video Guide for Sequim Washington

    Escaping California to the San Juan Islands

    Escaping California to the San Juan Islands

    Get Healthy

    Get Healthy: Increase Natural Immunities, Cellular Energy, Deep Sleep & Decrease Blood Pressure

    Manage Your Energy

    Manage Your Energy Not Your Time

    Real Estate Brokerage From Bricks and Mortar to High Tech Virtuality

    Real Estate Brokerage From Bricks and Mortar to High Tech Virtuality

    7 Myths of Selling Your Home

    7 Myths of Selling Your Home

    Buying Your Retirement Home

    Buying Your Retirement Home

    The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents

    The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents

    Sequim Real Estate For Buyers: Free eBook Updates Forever

    Sequim Real Estate For Buyers: Free eBook Updates Forever

    24 Secrets of Buying a Country Home

    24 Secrets of Buying a Country Home

    Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide

    Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide

    Living Off The Grid iin Alaska

    Living Off The Grid in Alaska

    Buying and Selling Real Estate

    Buying and Selling Real Estate

    Trending Tags

      • Sequim Real Estate for Buyers (Free eBook Updates Forever)
      • Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide (Paperback)
      • Escaping California to The San Juan Islands
      • Buying & Selling Real Estate in The Rain Shadow
      • Real Estate From Bricks & Mortar to High Tech Virtuality
      • The Seven Myths of Selling Your Home
      • Buying Your Retirement Home
      • The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents
    • Agents
      Marunde Google

      Chuck Marunde on Google

      Flat Fee Listing Broker

      Flat Fee Listing Broker

      Buyers Agent Chuck Marunde

      Buyer’s Agent Chuck Marunde

      Trending Tags

        • Buyers Agent Chuck Marunde
        • Flat Fee Listing Broker
        • Google Profile & Leave Reviews
      Tetralogy
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Login
      • Register
      • Home
      • Search MLS
        • Sequim MLS
        • Sequim MLS Map Search
        • Port Angeles MLS
        • Port Townsend MLS
        • San Juan Islands MLS
        • All Islands MLS
        • How to Search the Sequim MLS
      • Videos
        • Sequim Videos Q&A
        • Buyer Videos Part 1
        • Buyer Videos Part 2
        • Buyer Videos Part 3
        • Buyer Videos Part 4
        • Living in Sequim Video Channel
      • Books
        The Coming Real Estate Crash

        The Coming Real Estate Crash

        The Sequim Real Estate Trilogy

        The Sequim Real Estate Trilogy

        Sequim Real Estate Videos for Buyers: The Ultimate Video Guide for Sequim Washington

        Sequim Real Estate Videos for Buyers: The Ultimate Video Guide for Sequim Washington

        Escaping California to the San Juan Islands

        Escaping California to the San Juan Islands

        Get Healthy

        Get Healthy: Increase Natural Immunities, Cellular Energy, Deep Sleep & Decrease Blood Pressure

        Manage Your Energy

        Manage Your Energy Not Your Time

        Real Estate Brokerage From Bricks and Mortar to High Tech Virtuality

        Real Estate Brokerage From Bricks and Mortar to High Tech Virtuality

        7 Myths of Selling Your Home

        7 Myths of Selling Your Home

        Buying Your Retirement Home

        Buying Your Retirement Home

        The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents

        The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents

        Sequim Real Estate For Buyers: Free eBook Updates Forever

        Sequim Real Estate For Buyers: Free eBook Updates Forever

        24 Secrets of Buying a Country Home

        24 Secrets of Buying a Country Home

        Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide

        Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide

        Living Off The Grid iin Alaska

        Living Off The Grid in Alaska

        Buying and Selling Real Estate

        Buying and Selling Real Estate

        Trending Tags

          • Sequim Real Estate for Buyers (Free eBook Updates Forever)
          • Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide (Paperback)
          • Escaping California to The San Juan Islands
          • Buying & Selling Real Estate in The Rain Shadow
          • Real Estate From Bricks & Mortar to High Tech Virtuality
          • The Seven Myths of Selling Your Home
          • Buying Your Retirement Home
          • The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents
        • Agents
          Marunde Google

          Chuck Marunde on Google

          Flat Fee Listing Broker

          Flat Fee Listing Broker

          Buyers Agent Chuck Marunde

          Buyer’s Agent Chuck Marunde

          Trending Tags

            • Buyers Agent Chuck Marunde
            • Flat Fee Listing Broker
            • Google Profile & Leave Reviews
          No Result
          View All Result
          iRealty Virtual Brokers
          No Result
          View All Result
          Home Sequim Homes For Sale

          Buyers of Sequim Homes Discover Underwriter Nightmares: New Mortgage Problems for Buyers

          Chuck Marunde by Chuck Marunde
          September 27, 2019
          Reading Time: 9 mins read
          0 0
          1
          Mortgage

          Photo by Evan Dvorkin on Unsplash

          Buyers of Sequim homes have had their challenges since the collapse of the mortgage industry and the real estate market.  Even eminently qualified buyers of Sequim homes have had to jump unreasonable hurdles placed in their paths by evolving mortgage standards, including changing appraisal standards, and new processes in the underwriting industry.  All of this has not only hurt buyer’s, it has literally destroyed the ability of many sellers to get their Sequim homes sold.

          A new threat has arrived on the scene that hinders both buyers and sellers.  No one is talking about this, and I believe this is the first time this issue has been exposed and articulated in writing.

          Nearly everyone is aware of the higher standards that mortgage underwriters are requiring of buyers.  I don’t think any of us has a problem with the mortgage industry and their underwriters enforcing higher standards.  They should have beenSequim Homes paying attention to the standards before their industry collapsed.  Who could argue with an underwriter who wants a buyer to be qualified and proof that the property will secure the debt?  No one.  This is not the problem.  The problem is irrational and unreasonable demands by underwriters and their industry’s evolving rules and procedures.

          Underwriters Killing the Sale of Sequim Homes

          This is a true story.  A buyer makes an offer on a Sequim home, and the seller accepts the offer.  We have mutual acceptance.  We have a closing date, and we have a few contingencies to clear up before the closing date.  All perfectly normal, right?  The standard inspections include a septic inspection, a home inspection, but not a well inspection because the home is on a community well system.  The septic needs a new septic tank.  The seller agrees to replace it.  The home inspection goes very well, and the home inspector notes a few items on his report, which is normal.  Every home inspection report will have some items enumerated as the job of the home inspector is to find any possible items that may or could need to be replaced.  Obvious code violations will be noted in the report.  All that is good.  The buyers want to know if there are any issues of potential concern.  That’s why they hire the home inspector and pay him $400.

          This home inspection report noted a few minor items.  There was an outlet in the kitchen that didn’t have the mini-breaker switch built into it.  The door to the garage was a steel door but not a solid core door.  The composition shingle roof was seven years old and would need a few minor repairs.  And the hot water heater did not produce hot water.  It was suspected that the heater element was burned out.  All this is normal and these minor items have always been handled between buyer and seller by negotiating who would pay for the repairs, if any.  The form 35, which is the home inspection addendum, creates the need for a form 35R after the home inspection report, which addresses the needed repairs and asks the seller to pay for them.  The seller has an opportunity to agree or to seek to compromise the sharing of the cost of repairs.  This is the way we’ve been doing it for decades, and it is all a simple contract matter between the buyer and seller.

          Enter the underwriter.  The underwriter looked at the form 35R and saw that there was a home inspection report and that there were listed items that might need repair.  They were all minor, but the underwriter demanded a copy of the full home inspection report.  Here’s where the underwriter went off the reservation. 

          The underwriter required as a condition of him approving the loan, replacement of the kitchen outlet, the door from the kitchen to the garage, replacement of the hot water heater, and a certification by a roofer that the roof is good for at least two years.  At first blush none of that sounds unreasonable, but here is the danger and the trap for all of us.

          Sequim Homes and Underwriter Standards

          The underwriter’s job is to make sure the buyer is financially qualified to make monthly payments and pay off the loan and to make sure the property is good security for the debt.  In this case the buyer was putting down $100,000 cash on a $150,000 home.  The buyer had perfect credit and a nice retirement income.  So there was no problem with the buyer.  The only thing left for the underwriter was to make sure that this home, which appraised for above the purchase price, would be good security for the $50,000 loan.  Seems pretty simple, doesn’t it?  If you were the underwriter, would you feel secure making a $50,000 loan on a home that appraised for more than $150,000 when the buyer was putting $100,000 down?  Absolutely.  You would think this would be a no-brainer and the loan approval would be easy.  Based on loan to value ratio, this loan was only 33% of the appraised value.

          While the underwriter’s review of the home inspection report seems harmless on its face, here’s what was really happening.  The underwriter confused and mixed the standards for underwriting a loan with the standards for a home inspection.  These are two completely different industries with completely different purposes.

          The underwriter must determine the financial worthiness of the buyer and make sure the real estate is good security for the loan.  The underwriter orders an appraisal to determine it’s value.  The underwriter works for the mortgage company or bank, and indirectly works for the secondary mortgage market and the derivatives market.  Everyone in those industries is concerned about the buyer’s ability to make the monthly payments and to be secure in the real estate if the buyer cannot. 

          The home inspector works for the buyer, and has a completely different purpose and different standards.  The home inspector’s job is not to make sure the home’s value secures the loan.  The home inspector seeks to answer a simple question for the buyer, “Does this home have any structural or other mechanical issues that could effect my intended use and comfort in this home?”  The buyer wants to know if the home has any problems.  The buyer is already convinced of its value, and is willing to pay a home inspector $400 to find out if there is anything whatsoever that the home inspector can find wrong or even potentially wrong, even the most minute of issues.

          Here’s where the underwriter went wrong.  The underwriter made the home inspection report part of his underwriting standards.  He incorporated the home inspection report into his underwriting requirements.  He essentially made the home inspection report equal to the appraisal.  This mixed two completely different industry standards together for one underwriting purpose.

          The home inspection is not written for the purpose of determining the fair market value of the home.  It is written to satisfy the buyer’s curiosity about the comfort of the home and the working order of mechanical systems.  A buyer is not legally obligated to order a home inspection, and if he doesn’t, an underwriter cannot have one.  But when a buyer orders one, the underwriters are making these reports part of the underwriter standards.

          This means if the underwriter demands a copy of the home inspection report, the underwriter can delay the closing for weeks or months as he requires various repairs that have no effect at all on the security value of the home for lending purposes.  An underwriter may require that outlets be replaced, that doors be replaced, and that a licensed and bonded roofing contractor certify that a roof will last for two years.  Based on the home inspection report, an underwriter may irrationally demand that a step be repaired, that carpet be replaced, that a cabinet hinge be replaced, that a hot water heater be fixed, or that a window with a broken seal be replaced.  Repairs based on appraisal items is not unusual, but what we have now is repairs required based on non-appraisal items in a home inspection report.   Is the underwriter in a good mood today or a bad mood?  You’d better hope he is in a good mood, because no one can talk to him.  We don’t have his phone number or even his location in the country.  An underwriter not only has the power of God (and is just as inaccessible), he also can be completely irrational and buyers and sellers have no recourse.

          In the transaction I write about here, the entire transaction was at risk because the underwriter lost his focus on his core responsibility and went completely off the reservation to require home inspection repairs that had nothing whatsoever to do with loan underwriting standards.  The underwriter was happy with the buyer’s qualifications, and the underwriter was happy with the appraisal.  When the underwriter learned there was an home inspection report, this is when he got off track and lost his focus.  The implications of this are that in any transaction, an underwriter may require repairs that neither the buyer nor seller are willing to pay for,  or the underwriter may require repairs that exceed the time limits for funding the loan.

          This has some appraisers now referencing the home inspection report in their appraisal report, and when an underwriter reads an appraisal that references a home inspection report, they think they are obligated to demand a copy of the full home inspection report. 

          So what is the practical result of this new nightmare for buyers and sellers?  Whenever laws get ridiculous and create hurdles for reasonable people causing great financial hardship, people start figuring out ways to get around the bureaucrats.  Underwriters who are bringing in the home inspection report as part of their underwriter standards are causing great stress and financial hardship for both buyers and sellers, who might lose the transaction if it cannot close on time.  An underwriter has the power to literally kill the deal when he brings in the home inspection report using different standards than those in his own industry. 

          If an underwriter delays or kills a transaction based on a home inspection report, he is also taking money from the buying Realtor and the selling Realtor, and let’s not forget the loan officer doesn’t get paid if the transaction doesn’t close.

          There are many people who are adversely effected by the foolish and unreasonable requirements of an underwriter who has lost his focus on his fundamental responsibilities.  They will figure out how to get around that underwriter.  What will they do?  What are they doing?

          Buyers, sellers, Realtors, and loan officers will stop making any mention of a home inspection report.  They may have a form 35 home inspection addendum which gives the buyer the right to walk away if something turns out to be wrong with the house, but they wont’ produce or mention a home inspection report in a form 35R, and they won’t have an addendum in writing that mentions anything about a home inspection or any repairs or any credit at closing or any adjustment to the purchase price.  In other words, they won’t put anything in writing that would put the underwriter on notice that there ever was a home inspection report. 

          This means a qualified buyer and a good appraisal will be the only things the underwriter has to look at, which is as it always has been and as it should be today.  This gets back to basic underwriter standards, and eliminates the underwriter’s inappropriate mixing of two industry standards with different purposes in such a way that the entire transaction could be at risk or even killed.

          The devil is in the details, of course, so how a Realtor and his clients will handle this legally and ethically is another matter.  Some will do so dishonestly, but they will get the deal closed.  Others, like me, will figure out how to do it right.  It’s hard enough to bring a buyer and seller together today, to get a good appraisal, and to get an underwriter to sign off.  We don’t need underwriters going off half cocked to make up new rules that are not required, not written down, confuse two industry standards, and that give them the power of God to kill any transaction anytime they want.  But all this is going to require some serious and careful contract drafting, isn’t it?  This is one time I am glad I was a real estate attorney for 20 years.

          If you’re a buyer or a seller, be absolutely certain you know exactly how you will handle several issues:  1.) the home inspection addendum, 2.) the form 35R Inspection Response, 3.) the language in the 35R and how you address any items that need repair, and 4.) whether and how you negotiate a credit at closing or reduce the purchase price.

          Last Updated on September 27, 2019 by Chuck Marunde

          Tags: Sequim Homes
          ShareTweet
          Chuck Marunde

          Chuck Marunde

          Chuck grew up in remote Alaska, graduated from the University of Alaska with a degree in Economics and Teacher Certification, and after teaching high school for two years, went to law school at Gonzaga University in Spokane, Washington. He served four years as a Captain and JAG in the USAF at Nellis AFB in Las Vegas. After practicing real estate law for 20 years in Washington, Chuck founded iRealty Virtual Brokers covering Sequim and the beautiful Olympic Peninsula. He is the author of 2,200 real estate articles and a dozen real estate books, and he produced over 100 real estate videos. Chuck combined his love for real estate and technology to create a massive Internet presence, and his articles and videos and books have been viewed by millions. Chuck is a well recognized real estate expert and his counsel is sought by other brokers and practicing attorneys around the country. Buyers from New York to Hawaii and from Florida to Alaska seek him out to retain him as their buyer's agent, and home owners around the State of Washington seek him out because of his new Flat Fee Listing Service. 

          Related Posts

          Homes Sold in Sequim
          Sequim Homes For Sale

          Sequim Homes: Pending and Sold

          January 23, 2021
          48
          The Perfect Home
          Sequim Homes For Sale

          What if I Lose Out On The Perfect Home?

          August 19, 2020
          6
          Sequim Homes
          Sequim Homes For Sale

          Sequim Homes Selling Fast and Very Fast

          June 28, 2020
          6
          Home Shortage in Sequim
          Sequim Homes For Sale

          Home Shortage in Sequim

          July 13, 2019
          2
          Backup Offer
          Buyers

          Should I Submit a Backup Offer on a Pending Transaction?

          March 8, 2019
          48
          Sequim Homes For Sale

          The Sequim Bell Curve: Sequim Homes Hard to Find

          June 20, 2018
          3
          Next Post

          Sequim Waterfront Property Now Available

          Buying Homes in Sequim This Week

          Comments 1

          1. Charley says:
            11 years ago

            This article scares the hell out of me. Makes you appreciate your present, mortgage free home even more. At retirement, who wants to get involved in this mortgage mess when it is just as easy to rent a summer home. Someone once made this comment to me: “New gigs can become old pretty quick” Sometimes, we find ourselves in the dream phase, and when reality kicks in, it may be too late to wake up.

            Solution: Rent a place for a couple of months, when you have had enough, you know you always have your home to return to. There are numerous vacation rentals in Sequim or Port Angels with stunning views and more. Why buy ?????

            Reply

          Leave a Reply Cancel reply

          Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

          I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

          This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

          "I wish I read this before selling my
          home. I could have saved $50,000." Andy 

          Search 2,200 Articles by Category

          • Trending
          • Comments
          • Latest
          Buyer and Seller

          What if a Buyer and Seller Talk to Each Other?

          August 5, 2022
          Prorate Propane

          How to Prorate Propane at Closing

          August 15, 2015
          Terminate a real estate contract

          How to Terminate a Real Estate Contract

          December 31, 2020

          The Sequim Blue Hole – A Map of Rainfall

          September 1, 2019
          print newspapers

          Print Newspapers Losing Readers to the Internet

          42
          Buyer and Seller

          What if a Buyer and Seller Talk to Each Other?

          32
          FNMA Killing Transactions by Requiring Private Road Maintenance Agreements

          FNMA Killing Transactions by Requiring Private Road Maintenance Agreements

          31

          What Documents Does a Buyer Need to Buy Real Estate?

          24
          Sequim Real Estate Maps and Docs

          Sequim Real Estate Maps and Documents

          February 6, 2023
          Flat Fee Listing Service

          Sellers Chase the Market Down Once Again (UPDATED)

          March 22, 2023
          Sequim real estate market

          Sequim Real Estate Market: Annual Review for 2022

          February 3, 2023
          Seattle Real Estate Market in Decline

          Seattle Real Estate Market in Dramatic Decline

          December 22, 2022

          Subscribe to Chuck 
          Marunde's Newsletter

          Popular Stories

          • Buyer and Seller

            What if a Buyer and Seller Talk to Each Other?

            0 shares
            Share 0 Tweet 0
          • How to Prorate Propane at Closing

            0 shares
            Share 0 Tweet 0
          • How to Terminate a Real Estate Contract

            0 shares
            Share 0 Tweet 0
          • The Sequim Blue Hole – A Map of Rainfall

            0 shares
            Share 0 Tweet 0
          • Dangers of Buying a Fannie Mae Foreclosure Through Homepath

            0 shares
            Share 0 Tweet 0

          Leaving Comments   I hope you’ll join our community and leave comments from time to time. Please realize that comments, if approved, will be public, so do not use any personal information you don’t want broadcast to the world, and definitely don’t leave a phone number. Comments are not the place to ask Chuck Marunde for help in finding a home. To do that, call or text Chuck.

          Neither Chuck Marunde nor iRealty Virtual Brokers offers legal advice on this site. Please Read Our Legal Disclaimer

          If you’d like to view how we protect your privacy, see our Privacy Policy.

          iRealty Virtual Brokers

          iRealty Virtual Brokers reaches out to buyers around the United States with thousands of online articles, MLS sites, apps, real estate books, videos, and much more specifically to help buyers find all the answers to their questions. We also now offer a flat fee commission listing service that saves sellers tens of thousands of dollars.

          iRealty Virtual Brokers
          125 Olympic Ranch Ln
          Sequim, Washington 98382
          360-775-5424

          Search the entire NWMLS in Washington State:

          Sequim-Homes.com

          The largest independent real estate blog in the State of Washington with over 2,200 articles totally focused on our client’s best interest, their needs and their curiosity. All free and 100% reliable. I’m here if you need me, 

          © 2006-2022 iRealty Virtual Brokers and Chuck Marunde

          No Result
          View All Result
          • Home
          • Search MLS
            • Sequim MLS
            • Sequim MLS Map Search
            • Port Angeles MLS
            • Port Townsend MLS
            • San Juan Islands MLS
            • All Islands MLS
            • How to Search the Sequim MLS
          • Videos
            • Sequim Videos Q&A
            • Buyer Videos Part 1
            • Buyer Videos Part 2
            • Buyer Videos Part 3
            • Buyer Videos Part 4
            • Living in Sequim Video Channel
          • Books
            • Sequim Real Estate for Buyers (Free eBook Updates Forever)
            • Sequim Real Estate: A Buyer’s Guide (Paperback)
            • Escaping California to The San Juan Islands
            • Buying & Selling Real Estate in The Rain Shadow
            • Real Estate From Bricks & Mortar to High Tech Virtuality
            • The Seven Myths of Selling Your Home
            • Buying Your Retirement Home
            • The New World of Marketing for Real Estate Agents
          • Agents
            • Buyers Agent Chuck Marunde
            • Flat Fee Listing Broker
            • Google Profile & Leave Reviews
          • Login
          • Sign Up

          © 2006-2022 iRealty Virtual Brokers and Chuck Marunde

          Welcome Back!

          Login to your account below

          Forgotten Password? Sign Up

          Create New Account!

          Fill the forms bellow to register

          *By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
          All fields are required. Log In

          Retrieve your password

          Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

          Log In
          This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.